If you are playing Tainted Grail, you will face a big choice early in the story. Should you kill Caradoc or not in Tainted Grail? This guide will help you decide. You will see what happens if you kill him, what happens if you spare him, and how your choice changes your game.
Caradoc is one of the first key people you meet in Tainted Grail. He is a strong fighter and has his own reasons for what he does. When you meet him in the prison, you can choose to fight him or let him live. This choice shapes your story in different ways.
Many players wonder, should you kill Caradoc or not in Tainted Grail? Your answer leads to new scenes, rewards, and even changes the way King Arthur’s soul speaks to you.
What Happens If You Kill Caradoc?
If you decide to fight and kill Caradoc, the game rewards you with some rare loot. You will find a special sword called Wolf’s Howl and some unique gear on his body.
You will also get a mysterious letter, though you cannot read it. After you escape, you can light a bonfire and talk to Arthur’s soul. Arthur will praise you for your strong choice.
He will talk about the pin you took from Caradoc and say it is important for your journey.
Caradoc will not appear again in your story. This path gives you an achievement called “No Chains, No Destiny.” If you want rare loot early and do not mind missing out on more talks with Caradoc, this path is for you.
What Happens If You Spare Caradoc?
If you choose to let Caradoc live, you will meet him again after you escape. He waits for you by the boat near the coast. He will ask you some questions about what happened to you.
Here, you face another choice. You can tell him the truth about King Arthur’s soul, or you can lie. Many players feel unsure at this moment, since your choice here leads to two different secret endings.
If you want to be honest, your dialogue path looks like this:
- “I ran into some trouble along the way.”
- “I…found King Arthur.”
- “What are you talking about?”
If you want to lie to Caradoc, you can choose these lines:
- “I have no idea what happened to me.”
- “I told you – I have no idea.”
- “I don’t care about all of that.”
If you tell Caradoc the truth, he will attack you. He tries to end Arthur’s soul inside you, but he fails. After the fight, Caradoc will talk about hunting down the rest of Arthur’s soul.
Arthur will then talk to you at the bonfire and ask you to find the soul pieces first.
If you lie to Caradoc, he will stay suspicious, but he will not attack. You can then talk to Arthur’s soul at the bonfire.
Arthur’s words will change, and he will talk about your choice to hide the truth. In both cases, Caradoc stays in the story, and you may see him again later.
What if you ignore Caradoc?
Some players try to skip Caradoc by swimming to the island. If you do this, you will see a short scene where red priests catch you. They kill you, and you get a game over screen. This path ends your run early and does not let you see more of the story.
The big question, should you kill Caradoc or not in Tainted Grail, depends on what you want from your story. If you want rare loot and a quick achievement, killing Caradoc is a strong choice. If you want more story and extra scenes with Caradoc, let him live.
If you liked this article, you can check out our other article: How To Defeat Abigor in Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon and All Cooking Recipes in Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon.
